I used this before and I have to say that the color is fantastic. It is very thick and goes on thick, but not clumpy. If you like thick mascara then you'll love this! And it doesn't seem to smear easily. It seems to last longer, by this I mean there is a lot in the tube.
Great chestnut color, gives amazing volume, rarely smudges, doesnt dry out in the tube the way some products do. Great choice if you have short, sparse eyelashes. The brush has a unique shape that allows for even application.