I have used E. L. products for many years, and would usually rate them all a 4++++. This must have been old product the seller had. It was kind dry & just didn't have that creamy luxurious feel that their lipstick usually has. Also didn't stay on as well as normal, thus requiring multiple reapplications. These was also NO free gift as was stated in the description. Not too impressed.
i liked the first one i bought better, im experimenting with different make up for the first time in my life, really. just because this wasnt great for me, doesnt mean its not good, the cream just didnt work well for me. but i do love this brand.