Top critical review
on November 29, 2012
I received the product way earlier than the estimated shipping date, which was great! However, the package was damaged and not sealed ( the mascara and eyeliner were not just in the envelope with the back paper in there looking like it was ripped open). I worried that the product may have been used but when I opened the mascara it didn't have any of the liquid all over the top so I decided that it probably wasn't used and chose to keep it. However, the brush was very dry, there isn't a lot of liquid in the mascara tube. Moreover, no matter how many coats I applied, the mascara does not lengthe. It simply coats your eyelashes with black liquid. Over applying it won't give add any length or volume to your eyelashes, it will just keep coating them and end up clumping. I am very disappointed.