It's fine. I was hoping for a very dark mascara, since this said "extreme black." And while the color IS black, it coats the lashes very lightly. I have to apply several coats before I start to see a difference. I'll keep it and use it, but I was definitely hoping for a little thicker of a mascara so that I wouldn't have to keep layering it on. But if you want something subtle, or if you have lighter lashes, then this will probably be useful to you.
I love this mascara! It gives your lashes a very natural look by not being too thick or caked on. Most people don't know you have anything on because it just accentuates your natural beauty rather than making you look fake or superficial