It's fine. I was hoping for a very dark mascara, since this said "extreme black." And while the color IS black, it coats the lashes very lightly. I have to apply several coats before I start to see a difference. I'll keep it and use it, but I was definitely hoping for a little thicker of a mascara so that I wouldn't have to keep layering it on. But if you want something subtle, or if you have lighter lashes, then this will probably be useful to you.