Top critical review
One person found this helpful
Good, but not The Best
on December 16, 2015
I absolutely love makeup and really enjoy finding great makeup products. (I've done makeup for two different weddings this past year.) This product isn't my favorite by far.
Pros: Its waterproof (even though the packaging doesn't say it is), and doesn't even come off that much in the shower! Definitely stays on all day and doesn't smudge once its on. Goes on even and doesn't clump. It tends to grab all the little bitty hairs and cover them evenly as well.
Cons: Every time I apply the mascara, it smudges on my eyelids horribly (I know how to apply mascara and other products aren't as messy as this one). Product smells quite strongly (almost like a mild spray paint smell)! And also, as other reviewers have stated, is VERY hard to take off. I have to rub eye makeup remover on my lashes for at least 2-3 minutes before it comes off. This pulls my lashes and doesn't feel very comfortable at all. Most people know its not best to wear waterproof mascara for everyday use...
(Pictures attached: I rubbed the mascara on my hand and took a picture once it was dry to show the final, dry color. Also in the other pictures, my right eye (left eye from your view) has the Covergirl Mascara applied; the other eye is my regular mascara.