I usually only wear eyeliner and mascara. I have used cover girl for years. I only wear black. I was very happy to get this deal that comes with 2 mascaras and 1 eyeliner. My favorite is the eyeliner. It goes on very smooth even if your eyelid is wet. My only issue is with the twist up eyeliner you can never tell how much you have left so you should always keep a back up in your bag.I would buy this again.