Top critical review
One person found this helpful
It smells like it is old mascara as well
on December 18, 2014
The color is off black and actually looks grey on the brush. It smells like it is old mascara as well. I gave it two stars because it arrived on time. I will not be buying this product again. The brush applicator is not the best either. I do not have thick lashes so it doesn't do anything for me. It could be light coverage for someone who has thick lashes to begin with.